In Depth Analysis: CalculatedRisk Newsletter on Real Estate (Ad Free) Read it here.

Tuesday, August 16, 2005

Housing: Record Prices, Growing Caution

by Calculated Risk on 8/16/2005 12:20:00 AM

Amid stories of record home prices are signs of caution. Like these comments:

"Up until two weeks ago, the overwhelming number of professional articles and opinions rendered was that there is no housing bubble. Now more and more people are starting to refute the evidence that there isn't a bubble," DeSalvo [commercial broker with Premier Properties] said. "That is not to say that the market is going to crash but that it is going to slow down."

"The immediate danger in that is with rising interest rates, mortgage rates are going to pick up and it is going to create a different kind of real estate environment," he said. "Those that got the adjustable mortgages and the interest-only mortgages will be the first ones to tumble when that happens."

DeSalvo said another danger is that people getting high-risk loans now are going to try to sell as soon as the market starts to level off to get their money out.

"Everybody was doing it in the stock market, now everyone is doing it in real estate," DeSalvo said. "If they are lucky they will get away with their skin."
And from National Association of Realtors spokesman Walter Molony:
Perhaps the most interesting aspect of the current market is the high amount of residential speculation, he said. People are getting equity lines on their existing homes because of the appreciation and investing it in another house or property.

"The immediate danger in that is with rising interest rates, mortgage rates are going to pick up and it is going to create a different kind of real estate environment," he said. "Those that got the adjustable mortgages and the interest-only mortgages will be the first ones to tumble when that happens."

Real estate has traditionally been a long-term investment market and it should remain that way, Molony said. Instead, real estate has become the new stock market — the place for everyone to look to make a quick buck, even if that means taking out a high-risk loan, he said.

"That is very risky behavior. You cannot count on an abnormal market indefinitely," Molony said. "People are getting excited about buying homes in a hot market and there are loan officers out there who do not have a historical perspective and have never experienced a market with increasing rates and declining rates."
And from Economy.com's Analyst Gus Faucher:
"We're worried about a bubble in the housing market," said Economy.com's Faucher. But he does not envision the sort of splat that flattened stocks after the dotcom collapse.

"We expect that (increases in) house prices could slow or even turn negative on the coasts because those have seen the biggest run," he said.
And finally from Edward Edward Leamer of UCLA's Anderson Forecast:
He thinks that correction is coming and that it will be a doozy. "The situation gets worse and worse," he said, referring to "the elevation of prices beyond their fundamental values."

Leamer said eight of the last 10 housing corrections since World War II have precipitated recessions, the two exceptions being in the early 1950s and early 1960s, when spending on wars in Korea and Vietnam sustained growth.